ConflictMeter Methodology

How ConflictMeter works

ConflictMeter is an independent operationalisation of Professor David Betz’s published civil-conflict theories. It measures how closely current conditions in a country align with the structural, mobilisation and accelerant conditions that Betz argues make large-scale civil unrest and internal political conflict more likely. The production model is frozen as Betz v13.15 and is designed to be inspected rather than treated as a black box.

A higher ConflictMeter score means stronger alignment with those conditions. It is not a percentage probability, a prediction that conflict will occur, or a forecast of when it might occur. Traditional political risk analysis and country risk assessment usually cover a wider range of sovereign, commercial and operational risks; ConflictMeter deliberately measures a narrower internal-conflict conditions construct. ConflictMeter is not produced or endorsed by Professor Betz. See Betz, “Civil War Comes to the West” (2023) and Part II: Strategic Realities (2025).

Structural conditions are not organised violence

ConflictMeter measures structural conditions, mobilisation and bounded accelerants associated with a particular theory of internal-conflict risk. These indicators should not be confused with observations that organised violence has actually begun.

Political dissatisfaction, institutional distrust, identity fracture, demographic change, polarisation and mobilisation may all be relevant to an assessment of underlying conditions. None of them, alone or in combination, establishes that organised political violence is occurring or that it is imminent.

For that distinction, the Uppsala Conflict Data Program (UCDP) provides an external reference point. UCDP records defined forms of organised violence—including state-based armed conflict, non-state conflict and one-sided violence—using explicit criteria concerning actors, armed force and fatalities. Its Georeferenced Event Dataset records individual events of fatal organised violence at a particular place and time.

ConflictMeter does not reproduce, replace or reclassify UCDP event data. A high ConflictMeter score therefore means only that the measured country conditions align comparatively strongly with the model’s specified structural and mobilisation conditions. It is not evidence that a UCDP-defined conflict or organised-violence event has occurred, and it should not be interpreted as evidence that one is imminent.

Readers who need to determine whether observed events meet established organised-violence definitions should consult the UCDP Methodology and the UCDP Georeferenced Event Dataset Codebook directly.

UCDP provided methodological guidance on this distinction and recommended the above UCDP resources. This should not be interpreted as UCDP endorsement or validation of ConflictMeter or its methodology.

THE THEORETICAL BASIS

Professor David Betz's civil-conflict thesis

ConflictMeter is based on a body of argument developed by Professor David Betz about the conditions that may make large-scale internal political conflict more likely in Western societies. The summary below describes Betz’s propositions; it should not be read as an independent finding by ConflictMeter, nor as a claim that every mechanism he discusses is directly scored by the index.

Status reversal / perceived downgrading

Betz gives particular weight to situations in which a previously dominant or established group perceives a loss of political, cultural or social status. In his 2023 essay he describes this as “downgrading” or status reversal and treats the perception itself as strategically important.

Factionalisation and social cohesion

His argument emphasises polarisation, declining trust and weakening social capital. The concern is not disagreement in the abstract, but whether society is fragmenting into antagonistic identity groups with less confidence in shared institutions and fewer cross-cutting bonds.

Loss of faith in normal politics

Across the essays, Betz argues that legitimacy and confidence in ordinary political mechanisms are central. When large groups cease to believe normal politics can resolve major grievances, extra-political alternatives become more conceivable.

Economic and generational expectation gaps

The 2025 Betz-Smith essay develops an expectation-gap argument: stagnating material prospects and blocked expectations, especially among younger and educated groups, may deepen grievance and reduce confidence that the existing system can deliver improvement.

Mobilisation, networks and narrative

Betz and Smith distinguish background grievance from the capacity to organise around it. They discuss mobilisation, narrative framing and digital networks as mechanisms that can turn private discontent into visible collective grievance, while also noting limits to online organisation for clandestine action.

Strategic consequences and system vulnerability

Betz’s later work goes beyond causes to the possible strategic character of internal conflict, including the vulnerability of highly connected urban systems and critical infrastructure. ConflictMeter treats this as theoretical context rather than a scored structural pillar.

How ConflictMeter operationalises the theory

ConflictMeter turns selected parts of this theory into observable, reproducible measures. Its three structural pillars correspond to Downgrading / Status Reversal, Factionalism and Loss of Faith in Normal Politics. Those conditions are combined as Pressure, while a separate Activation measure asks whether mobilisation capacity and intensity are present. Economic and narrative conditions act only as bounded accelerants.

That mapping is an independent operationalisation. Professor Betz does not produce the index, and no endorsement or affiliation should be inferred. ConflictMeter also does not attempt to score every proposition in his strategic analysis—for example, the detailed tactics of system disruption or every claimed cause of social fragmentation.

Read the source essays

The model in one minute

The headline score is built in three stages. First, three structural preconditions are combined into Pressure. Second, Pressure is combined with Activation using symmetric convergence. Finally, economic and narrative conditions can add a bounded accelerant effect.

1. Structural Pressure

Geometric convergence of Downgrading / Status Reversal, Factionalism and Loss of Faith in Normal Politics.

2. Activation

Current general mass mobilisation plus positive-only change over roughly ten years. It measures mobilisation intensity/capacity, not political violence itself.

3. Accelerants

Economic stagnation and narrative fragmentation can raise the Base score modestly. Each has a frozen 10% headroom coefficient.

Frozen production formula

v13.15 makes no methodological change to the v13.14 production candidate; it is the final QA/reproducibility freeze.

Precondition
P = geometric mean(P1, P2, P3)
Activation
A = mean(current mobilisation percentile, positive-only 10y change percentile)
Base
Base = √(P × A)
Gross
100 − (100 − Base) × (1 − 0.10E/100) × (1 − 0.10N/100)

Missing inputs remain NULL. ConflictMeter never substitutes zero or regional averages simply to keep a country in a ranking.

The three structural pillars

P1 — Downgrading / Status Reversal

Global: demographic-change velocity as a globally scalable proxy.

Enhanced: recent comparable subjective nativism/status evidence is added where available.

Actual political-power transitions remain context rather than a substitute for perceived status reversal.

P2 — Factionalism

Global: V-Dem political polarisation current level plus long-run change.

Enhanced: direct 2025 immigrant/native-born and inter-ethnic tension evidence where available.

P3 — Loss of Faith in Normal Politics

Global: Democracy Perception Index evidence for perceived democratic/institutional performance.

Enhanced: Ipsos Society is Broken Index 2025 where available.

What the accelerants do — and do not do

Economic pressure

World Bank WDI growth shortfalls are zero-preserving: no adverse shortfall means zero pressure. GDP-per-capita and household-consumption-per-capita shortfalls are combined arithmetically.

Inflation remains context-only rather than a scored accelerant.

Narrative fragmentation

V-Dem online-media fractionalisation provides the scored narrative-fragmentation channel using current adverse level and positive long-run deterioration.

Party hate speech remains context-only because it overlaps more strongly with Factionalism.

Containment

The universal headline is the Gross index. Democratic containment is already represented through legitimacy; there is no generic democratic safety brake.

Autocratic Net25 is a secondary sensitivity view, not the primary score.

Global and Enhanced are separate products

The Global model uses globally scalable inputs and is the basis for worldwide comparison. Enhanced uses additional recent direct-survey evidence where comparable coverage exists. They are never mixed into one ranking universe.

Global

96 countries currently have Pressure + Activation coverage.

81 have FULL current Global coverage including both accelerants.

Enhanced

30 countries have Enhanced Core + Activation coverage.

30 have FULL Enhanced coverage.

Coverage is information

A country without FULL coverage can still have legitimate partial current evidence or historical component history. ConflictMeter labels that state explicitly rather than manufacturing completeness.

Historical methodology

ConflictMeter separates what could have been known at the time from what today’s source databases now say about the same historical period.

Vintage

Uses the source release that was available by the historical cutoff. This is the public movement baseline from 2025 onward.

Reconstructed

Uses later revised source databases for the same historical period. It is kept separate so later source revisions are not mistaken for real historical change.

No synthetic backfill

Pre-2025 history remains component-only where full direct comparability is not authorised. ConflictMeter does not infer a retrospective headline score simply because most components exist.

2025 Vintage is the first authorised public headline baseline for forward score/rank movement. No pre-2025 headline history is published.

Source diagnostics are not risk components

Current Revision Sensitivity

Measures how much later source revisions changed the latest comparable historical observation. Public country pages show the classification; paid products can show the driver and magnitude.

Historical Revision Exposure

Summarises revision exposure across 2021–2025: maximum change, affected families and affected years.

Why expose this?

Many public datasets revise history. ConflictMeter distinguishes source revision from substantive historical movement rather than silently rewriting the record.

These are source diagnostics. They are not ConflictMeter components, confidence scores or measurement-uncertainty scores.

Versioning and change control

The active production methodology is Betz v13.15, frozen on 28 September 2026. Any future change to pillar definitions, source placement, Activation, interaction form, accelerant coefficients, containment treatment or missingness requires a new version and an explicit audit.

Scroll to Top